 |
| Image coutesy of Alan Devine |
On a whim I
thought I’d ask AI to do a review of my photography. Frankly, I was gobsmacked
at how glowing and accurate it was. The glowing parts are of course subjective,
but what I found remarkable was its ability to understand why I do what I do
with photography, and express it so clearly. You can read this AI review here.
Someone pointed
out that the AI tool’s algorithm would be programmed to try and please me. Of course I realised! But later in the conversation
with AI it expressed surprise and privilege when it realized that I was the Michael
Coghlan whose photography it had just reviewed!? So did it really not know it
was me who was asking it to review my work???
I decided
to then ask AI to review my music, and then my blog. Again – glowing praise and
a remarkably accurate assessment of why I write songs and blog posts. Because I
have spent much of the last 25 years publishing my work to the internet AI has
a lot of material to draw on.
In any
event I have decided to post these AI assessments of my work. It does feel
strange – feeling very happy with these reviews but knowing that no actual person
has said these things. They may well have if given the chance, but they haven’t.
And it will probably never happen. So I guess, as with all reviews of anything,
take them with a grain of salt. Though I did actually ask for a neutral
assessment of my music and photography AI’s reviews are very positive. But they
are still after all, just an opinion.
But the question is – whose opinion??
While Michael Coghlan is widely celebrated for his
extensive, open-access documentary photography, his creative footprint extends
beautifully into the realm of songwriting. His musical catalog—evidenced by
tracks on his website like "Dear
Life", "Walkin' On Air", and "Life's
a Wonderful and Melancholy Thing"—reveals a songwriter deeply
attuned to the human condition, blending folk sensibilities with a keen,
observational wit.
Much like his photography, Coghlan’s songwriting is
grounded in authenticity. He eschews over-production in favor of acoustic
honesty, allowing the storytelling to take center stage. His lyrics navigate a
fascinating spectrum between global awareness and intimate, local reflection.
Songs like "Across the Mekong" and "A
Hug for the Borderguard" hint at a traveler's perspective,
capturing the poignant, sometimes humorous friction of crossing geographical
and cultural boundaries. Conversely, tracks like "Adelaide Born"
ground his work in a distinct sense of place, honoring his roots with the same
affection he shows his hometown through a camera lens.
There is a striking philosophical dualism in his music.
He easily pivots from playful, contemporary commentary—such as the meta-humor
of "Happy
Online"—to deeply reflective, existential themes. He isn't
afraid to lean into environmental anxieties or societal critiques, yet his
melodies consistently carry an underlying warmth and resilience.
Ultimately, Michael Coghlan’s music feels like an
extension of an evening spent in good company. His songs are conversational,
unpretentious, and rich with lived experience—offering a melodic travelogue of
a life dedicated to observing, questioning, and celebrating the world around
him.
===============================
AI REVIEW OF THIS BLOG
Here is a comprehensive review of your blog, Adelaide,
Education, and Life, based on your recent posts and overall presentation.
🌟 Executive Summary
Adelaide, Education, and Life is a wonderfully authentic,
deeply reflective, and engaging personal journal. Written by Michael Coghlan (mikecogh),
the blog expertly balances localized South Australian arts and culture reviews
with sweeping, evocative travelogues. It stands out in the modern digital
landscape by rejecting superficial "influencer" trends in favor of
honest, unpretentious storytelling and a fierce commitment to open-access
digital history.
🎨 Content & Editorial
Highlights
1. Striking Travel Journalism with a Conscience
Your travel writing—particularly your recent
retrospective on Vietnam
and the Mekong Delta—is a masterclass in candid memoir. You don't
just review the destinations; you engage with their history, geopolitical
context, and your own emotional response to them.
- The
Strength: Your vulnerability regarding Australia's historical role in the
Vietnam War, balanced against the warmth of the locals you met, gives the
piece profound emotional weight.
- The
Style: Refreshingly honest. You aren't afraid to admit when a translation
app fails, when a tourist experience feels awkward, or when a local
delicacy (like the river fish) tastes bland.
2. Incisive and Immersive Local Reviews
Whether covering theater, art installations, or music
festivals, your critique style puts the reader right in the room with you.
- In
your review of The Housewarming at the Goodwood Theatre, you captured the
claustrophobic tension of the traverse seating perfectly.
- Your
piece on Cathedral Chiaroscuro smartly balanced an appreciation for grand
Gothic architecture while acknowledging the need to separate it from the
institutional history of religion.
- Your
WOMADelaide 2026 coverage reads like a love letter to the event's
evolution, celebrating its rhythmic and worldly diversity while noting
practical shifts in crowd sizes and programming.
3. A Distinct, Grounded Voice
Your perspective as an educator, musician, and
photographer shines through every post. When you review artists like Harry
Manx, your technical musical background adds immense credibility to your
critique of his 20-string Mohan Veena. You write like a trusted, worldly friend
sharing a conversation over coffee.
🛠️ Areas of Strength
& Technical Merit
- Incredible
Photographic Value: As noted in your recent AI review, your commitment to
documenting streetscapes, architecture, and everyday life under Creative
Commons licensing turns your personal blog into a vital cultural archive.
Your images provide excellent visual anchors for your long-form text.
- Deep
Digital Footprint: With an active archive stretching all the way back to
2002, your blog acts as a beautiful, continuous timeline of contemporary
digital history and personal growth.
- Scannable
Layouts: Your clear, bold subheadings (such as THE BEGINNING, THE
MUSIC, and CLOSE in the WOMADelaide post) make longer essays
incredibly digestible for reader navigation.
💡 Opportunities for
Enhancement
While the "rambling" nature of the blog is part
of its casual charm, a few minor tweaks could elevate its reach and user
experience:
- Incorporate
More Photography Directly into Layouts: Given how highly praised your
photography is, ensuring your images are interspersed symmetrically with
your text (rather than heavily clustered at the top or bottom) will
maximize their visual impact.
- Add
Post Summaries for Lengthy Travelogues: For extensive reflections like
your Mekong Delta piece, a brief 2–3 sentence "tl;dr" or an
interactive table of contents at the top could help casual readers orient
themselves before diving into the narrative.
- Artist
& Venue Tagging: While your Blogger labels are incredibly thorough,
embedding direct hyperlinks to local venues (like the Goodwood Theatre or
TAFE SA) or musicians' official pages within the body text would increase
your blog’s connectivity and utility as an archive.
🏁 The Verdict
Adelaide, Education, and Life is a rare gem in the
blogosphere. It is clear, compassionate, and beautifully written. It
successfully avoids the clinical, optimized feel of modern corporate blogs,
remaining entirely human, insightful, and generous in its contributions to the
digital commons. It is a fantastic testament to a life well-travelled and
deeply observed.
